We often think of nationalism as a conservative force. It conjures images of right-wing populism, imperial conquest, and aggressive exclusion.
But in the first half of the nineteenth century, nationalism was a radical, left-wing idea. It was the dream of liberals who believed that if people were allowed to govern themselves based on their shared language and culture, the world would become more peaceful, not less.
How did a movement for freedom become a catalyst for world war? This is the story of how nationalism evolved, from the utopian dreams of Giuseppe Mazzini to the cynical realpolitik of Otto von Bismarck.
The Congress of Vienna's Impossible Task
In the nineteenth century, nationalism was defined by language and cultural traditions. It was the quest to establish national states whose borders corresponded to patterns of ethnic residence.
This was a nightmare for the diplomats at the Congress of Vienna. They wanted to restore the old order, but they were dealing with deeply mixed populations. The Habsburg empire alone had eleven major nationalities, including Hungarians and Poles. Trying to draw borders based on ethnicity was like trying to cut a cake that was already mixed into a batter.
Not every attempt at nationalist reform ended in bloodshed. Switzerland offered a rare success story. The Congress had established it as a federation of semi-autonomous cantons. Because they had a long tradition of decentralized government, the Congress tolerated a relatively liberal constitution. Inspired by the 1830 revolution in France, Swiss liberals pushed for limits on the influence of the clergy. After some limited fighting, by 1848 Switzerland adopted a new liberal constitution. It was a quiet triumph of compromise.
Poland, however, was the tragedy. The Congress left about twenty percent of pre-partition Poland as "Congress Poland," trapped inside the Russian Empire with a powerless parliament. When Polish military cadets rose up against the Russians in 1830, they formed a provisional government. But the might of the Russian Empire was too much. By the autumn of 1832, Warsaw fell. Ten thousand Poles fled, including artists and musicians like Frederic Chopin, who moved to Paris and enriched the cultural life of Western Europe. Back home, Polish privileges disappeared.
The Utopian Dreamers
In Italy, the situation was fragmented. Austria dominated the peninsula, and unification remained a dream for middle-class intellectuals. One of the most energetic of those intellectuals was Giuseppe Mazzini. A trained lawyer and a fiery revolutionary, Mazzini wanted to bring peace to Europe by liberating all people. He even suggested creating a federation of European democratic republics.
Mazzini rejected classic liberalism as devoid of moral values, and rejected socialism as overly materialistic. He believed unification had to be the work of the people themselves, not just the expansion of a single state. He supported King Charles Albert of Piedmont-Sardinia for leadership, but the revolutions of 1848 proved how fragile these dreams were.
When revolutionaries challenged the Pope's authority in the Papal States, the Pope called for their overthrow. A Roman Republic was proclaimed in February 1849, and Mazzini arrived to join the revolutionary government. But the French intervened to support the Pope, occupying Rome. The only government to survive from 1848 into 1849 was the Venetian Republic, and by 1851 almost everything was back to pre-1848. Mazzini spent the next decade in mourning. An 1853 insurrection in Lombardy failed when the Austrians were tipped off.
In the German states, a similar intellectual awakening was happening. Johann Gottlieb Fichte called upon "the German nation" during the times of Napoleon, defining it broadly as anyone who spoke German. Liberalism gained momentum among professors, students, and lawyers. Thinkers like Hegel linked liberalism to unification. The creation of the German Customs Union (Zollverein) in 1834 laid the economic groundwork for a unified nation.
But utopian dreams were not what actually built nations.
Italian unification came not because of the utopian nationalism of Giuseppe Mazzini, nor because of the frenzied dashes of Giuseppe Garibaldi, but rather largely as a result of the expansion of Piedmont-Sardinia, the peninsula's strongest and most liberal state.
The Great Flip: From Left to Right
As the century progressed, the nature of nationalism changed. In the first half of the 1800s, liberals and nationalists were often the same people. But by the end of the 19th century, nationalists became convinced that their people were superior to any other. The ideology was hijacked by the right wing.
A new generation of conservative leaders, among them Napoleon III, Cavour in Italy, and Bismarck in Germany, realized they could use popular nationalism to strengthen the state, rather than to liberate the people. Nationalism was no longer just a dream of freedom; it was a tool for top-down state-building.
This aggressive nationalism easily merged with imperialism. The great powers believed they were entitled to dominate "inferior" peoples through empire expansion. This "New Imperialism" began in the 1880s. By 1914, European powers had divided three-quarters of the world. Europe was split in two: Germany and Austria-Hungary versus Britain, France, and Russia.
The Dual Monarchy
The Habsburg empire struggled to contain its diverse nationalities. After losing a war to Prussia in 1866, they faced a crisis: the Magyars (Hungarians) demanded more power. Emperor Francis Joseph feared they would ally with German liberals.
So, in 1867, they reached the Ausgleich (Compromise). It created the Dual Monarchy of Austria-Hungary. Hungarian became the language of administration in Hungary, and the Magyar domains had their own constitution and parliament.
But this did not solve the nationality problem. Austria dominated the Dual Monarchy, and none of the other nationalities were happy. The Hungarian government began a policy of Magyarization, forcing Hungarian language and culture on other groups. Count Eduard von Taffe, the Austrian prime minister from 1879 to 1893, tried to balance these competing interests, particularly the Czechs, but it was a constant tightrope walk.
Anti-Semitism as a Unifying Force
As nationalism became exclusionary, hostility toward Jews became a unifying factor for many nationalists in the late 19th century. Nothing illustrates this darker shift better than the Dreyfus Affair in France.
In 1894, evidence emerged that the Germans had a spy in the French military. Based on circumstantial evidence, a Jewish captain from Alsace named Alfred Dreyfus was accused. He was innocent, but the army court-martialed him and sent him to Devil's Island. High-ranking officers believed it was better to have an innocent Jew languishing in depression than to compromise the army's public image.
When the press got involved in 1898 and the army was accused of a cover-up, the right wing and the Church jumped to the anti-Dreyfus side. It put the army, Church, and monarchists against republicans and socialists. Families were split against each other. Dreyfus was retried in 1899, found guilty with "extenuating circumstances," and returned to his family a broken man. He was not fully exonerated until 1906.
This anti-Semitism was not limited to France. In Vienna, where Sigmund Freud had moved as a child, the atmosphere shifted drastically after the economic depression of 1873. In 1895, the anti-Semite Karl Lueger was elected mayor, famously declaring, "I decide who is a Jew."
The Church and the Social Question
In Catholic countries, the Church had traditionally been an alternative to nationalism. But as the Church's influence was reduced and institutions became secularized, the Pope and Rome fought back against nation-states and parliamentary government.
In 1864, Pope Pius IX issued the Syllabus of Errors, condemning the idea that the Pope should reconcile with progress, liberalism, and modern civilization. In 1870, he established the Doctrine of Papal Infallibility.
But the Church had to adapt. In 1891, Pope Leo XIII issued Rerum Novarum, accepting the modern world and calling attention to social injustice. An unintended effect was the rise of Christian Socialist movements in France, Germany, Belgium, and Italy in the 1890s.
Zionism and the Aftermath
While western European Jews were becoming more socially acculturated, a new form of Jewish nationalism developed late in the century as a response to this growing anti-Semitism.
Between 1871 and 1914, 1.5 million Jews left Russia and Polish Russia for the United States. The Zionist movement advocated for the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine. There was even support from the British, who saw a Jewish state as a useful buffer between the Suez Canal and Syria. Palestine was part of the Ottoman Empire at the time, but by 1914, 85,000 Jews were living there.
The nationality question did not go away. It resurfaced with a vengeance in the aftermath of World War One. At the Versailles peace talks, representatives of ethnic, religious, and national groups, including the Irish, Persians, Jews, Arabs, Indians, Vietnamese, Armenians, and African Americans, all went in the hope of attaining recognition of their natural rights.