What Most Investing Games Get Wrong

By James Riggs · 5 min read

Most investing games teach students to be gamblers.

They hand over a portfolio, let students buy and sell, then crown whoever made the most money as the winner. The message lands hard: swing big, pick the risky stock, go for the moonshot.

That's not investing. It's lottery thinking with a chart.

When I built Stock Safari, I had four specific problems in mind. Each one is common to most educational finance games. Each one is fixable.

Problem 1: No baseline to beat

Most games measure success against a peer group. Whoever wins, wins. But winning a class competition doesn't tell you whether you made good decisions. A student who puts everything on the risky stock and gets lucky is celebrated. A student who makes careful, diversified choices and finishes second is invisible.

The fix is embarrassingly simple: give students a baseline they have to beat.

In Stock Safari, students can put money into a piggy bank that earns 1% interest every week. No drama, no volatility, no news events. Just slow compounding. Over ten weeks, that $1,000 becomes about $1,105.

At the end of the game, the comparison isn't against the other students. It's against the piggy bank. If you didn't beat 1% a week, you didn't make good decisions regardless of where you finished in the class.

This changes the game completely. Students start thinking about risk-adjusted returns without anyone having to use those words.

Problem 2: Volatility has to be felt, not explained

You can tell a student that stocks are volatile. They'll nod. Then they'll put all their money into the highest-returning option and act surprised when it crashes.

Volatility has to be experienced. It has to happen to their money, in their portfolio, while they're watching.

The four stocks in Stock Safari have distinct personalities:

  • SnackCo a boring cookie company. Low risk, low return.
  • RoboCorp sleek robots. Medium risk, medium return.
  • GreenGrow eco farming tech. A bit wild.
  • MoonCoin trendy cryptocurrency. Super risky.

Owning MoonCoin is a different experience from owning SnackCo. It jumps 30% one week and drops 25% the next. If a student has a meaningful position, they feel it. Not abstractly, actually.

By the end of ten weeks, they've learned something about risk that no lecture could have taught them.

Problem 3: The ending should teach, not rank

Most educational games end with a score. Sometimes a leaderboard. What they rarely end with is a lesson.

The end screen of Stock Safari shows three things:

  • Your final net worth, and how it compares to the piggy bank.
  • The market's top performer which stock grew the most, regardless of whether you owned it.
  • Your best trade which stock you actually made the most money on.

That last one matters. It doesn't say "you won." It says "here's what you did well, and here's what you could have done better." A student who never bought MoonCoin sees that MoonCoin was the market's winner and learns what they missed. A student who bought too much MoonCoin sees their own best trade was small by comparison and learns that concentration cut into their returns.

The screen ends with five short principles drawn from the game: diversify, understand risk and reward, don't panic sell, time beats timing, only invest what you can afford to lose.

None of those principles are new. But they mean more when they arrive attached to a specific loss.

Problem 4: No dark patterns

This is the one I care about most, and the one most finance games ignore.

Real investing apps are designed to keep you trading. Streaks, urgency, social proof, notifications, FOMO, they use every trick in the behavioural economics textbook to make you feel like you should be doing something right now. Most educational games copy these patterns because they're what students recognise.

I think that's backwards. Education should be where students learn to resist those patterns, not where they get trained into them.

So Stock Safari has none of them. No streak rewards. No "everyone else is buying SnackCo." No countdown timers, no notifications, no achievement popups. The pace is slower than a real trading app on purpose.

The game ends at week ten whether you played perfectly or terribly. There's no way to keep going. No daily rewards. No way to log back in for another session.

It's designed to be a short, complete experience and then to stop.

What students take away

A ten-week game won't teach a student how to invest. It can't. That takes years, and this is a simplified model with cartoon stocks and news events like "MoonCoin's founder vanishes with the office coffee machine."

But it can teach something that sticks: what it feels like to make a decision with money on the line, and what happens when it goes wrong.

That's a more honest starting point than most finance education.

Play Stock Safari →
Free, runs in any browser, takes about ten minutes.


If you're using it with students and want to compare notes or you've found a finance game that does this better get in touch.

Read next